Learn about our Team and Culture
We are a team of dedicated professionals, ready to do whatever it takes to earn your business.
Tom began his career with Nautilus Insurance Group in January 1986 and has served as President and Chief Executive Officer since October 1997. Tom previously held the position of Vice President of Underwriting before moving to his current position within the company. He has over 35 years of experience in the Excess and Surplus Lines industry focusing on Commercial Property and Casualty insurance. He holds a Bachelor of Science in Business Administration from Arizona State University and attained the Associate in Risk Management (ARM) designation in 1991.
Tom has worked in the insurance industry for 30 years and is currently the Sr. Vice President and Chief Underwriting Officer for Nautilus. Tom worked for St. Paul Fire & Marine Insurance Company in various technical and leadership roles and then spent the past 20 years with the Scottsdale Insurance Group, most recently as Vice President of Claim Operations. Tom earned a Bachelor of Science degree from Northern Arizona University, and holds a number of professional designations, including an Associate in Surplus Lines Insurance and Associate in Claim Law.
Allison began her career with Nautilus Insurance Group in April of 2018 as Senior Vice President and Chief Finance Officer. Previously, she served as Director of P&C Investment Accounting at AIG before becoming Vice President, Property Casualty Statutory Controller. Allison holds a Bachelor’s degree in Accounting and is a CPA.
Trish has more than 33 years of experience in the Excess & Surplus Lines insurance industry with significant expertise in leading project management and strategic business initiatives. After joining Nautilus in 2016, she served as Vice President of Business Strategic Projects while leading the design and implementation of a claims management system. Prior to Nautilus, Trish worked as a Claims leader at a Fortune 100 insurance carrier. She holds a Master’s degree in Applied Communication from Northern Arizona University, and a Bachelor of Science in Psychology from Marymount College.
Wendy began her career with Nautilus Insurance Group in May 1986 and is currently serving as Senior Vice President, Agency Development. Wendy became an officer of Nautilus in October 1997. Her tenure with Nautilus includes Chief Underwriting Officer, Senior Property Casualty Underwriter, Underwriting Assistant Manager and Manager of the Product Development unit. She holds the Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter (CPCU) designation.
Karen began her career with Nautilus Insurance Group in April of 2016 and leads Human Resources. She comes to Nautilus from Terros Health, where she served as Senior Director of Human Resources. Karen has over 19 years of human resources experience in a variety of industries, and has been leading HR teams for over 10 years. She holds Bachelor of Arts (Communication) and Master of Business Administration degrees, as well as SPHR and SHRM-SCP senior human resources professional designations.
Thomas Pytel, Jr.
Tom began his career with Nautilus Insurance Group in December of 2014 and leads Marketing and Communications. He comes to Nautilus Insurance Group from CAMICO Mutual Insurance Company, where he served as vice president of Marketing and Communications, Direct Sales and Agency Management. Previously, Tom worked for Allied World Assurance Company where he served as assistant vice president and the creative lead for all global marketing and product marketing initiatives. He holds a Bachelor of Fine Arts degree from Rhode Island School of Design.
Joel has been a claims professional since 1990 and is currently Vice President and Chief Claims Officer for Nautilus. Prior to joining Nautilus, Joel worked at Scottsdale Insurance Group for 21 years, where he held both technical and leadership positions, the most recent being Director of Casualty Claims, Eastern Region. Before moving to Arizona, Joel was a field claims professional in northwest and north central Indiana. Joel holds a Bachelor of Arts degree from Purdue University as well as the CPCU, RPLU, and ASLI designations.